X Factor USA Review: Arin Ray & Beatrice Miller Eliminated

X Factor USA Review: Arin Ray & Beatrice Miller Eliminated

The X Factor USA’s Thanksgiving special claimed two more as Arin Ray and Beatrice Miller were sent to the chopping block. It was expected that Arin might not make it through, considering his position in the rankings. His grandmother had lashed out at his mentor Britney Spears publicly for being what she referred to as “poor mentor”, but America has spoken and Arin was eliminated right off of the bat.

What came as a shock to us was that Beatrice Miller has been eliminated from the show. She went head-to-head with Cece Frey in the final sing-off and was still voted off of the show. Cece performed a seriously sub-par rendition of “Because Of You” by Kelly Clarkson, while Beatrice Miller delivered an excellent version of Dido’s “White Flag”.

Let’s critique Cece’s performance because we really thought she was trying to throw the competition and give the win to Beatrice. When Beatrice learned that she was facing Cece in the sing-off, Cece consoled her while on stage, telling her over and over “it’s alright”. Still Cece’s singing was completely pitchy and just all-around off. This is the girl who has already proven her mettle with a Whitney Houston performance, so we know she’s got the chops. But her Kelly Clarkson song left a lot to be desired. Was it a conspiracy?!?

Why was Beatrice eliminated from the top eight? Britney still has Carly Rose Sonenclar and Diamond White under her wings, so we’re not counting her out just yet. We are still of the mind that Carly Rose is going to take the “X Factor” season two crown, but not without a fight from Tate Stevens or Vino Alan. All of the others are just fluff until the final showdown. What do you think?

So far this season who has been getting your votes on the show? Who do you think is going to win?

11 Responses

  1. Chuck Rowland November 24, 2012 / 1:40 PM

    Diamond white and carly are the best two. Vino sounds the same on every song. And tate can poop on the stage and still win cause white people love country. Hello white america.

    • earsucker November 24, 2012 / 2:07 PM

      We here at Earsucker hate country music.

      • Chuck Rowland November 24, 2012 / 2:26 PM

        Maybe you hate country music. But my auntie in texas love that shit and she is white(cool as a fan). And tate is not wack but he is not that good. Carly is great can’t deny. Diamond is too. She say the same about rap so I guess.its not all whites but its most.

        • Nvcola November 25, 2012 / 4:29 AM

          You’re an idiot… and coming in aroud an 8 out of 10 on the racist/douche meter. Miller was robbed, I’m calling shenanigans.

  2. Chuck Rowland November 24, 2012 / 1:44 PM

    Its fixed for carly but that little ugly azz girl can sang. She just funny looking. But vocally she is good. No doubt she will win she has all the qualifications. Young, white,and can sing.young black girl that can sing don’t stand a chance. But tate is good but he isn’t that good. White folks love country music. E3 is trash

    • asdfghjkl November 24, 2012 / 1:56 PM

      lmao, this comment makes me laugh.

      • Chuck Rowland November 24, 2012 / 2:31 PM

        which part E3 is trash. Carly qualifications. Or majority of white people love country like most blacks love rap.which part she do make some ugly faces but she can sing hands down I can’t take that awayfrom her. But how do E3 rank higher than diamond how do tate rank higher than carly. Please explain

  3. Kate W. November 24, 2012 / 1:54 PM

    Is this show still on air? Simon says, time to cancel this debacle.

  4. Kathryn Hopkins November 24, 2012 / 5:15 PM

    I’m very disappointed to see Beatrice Miller leave the show, I loved her voice and would definitely buy every song she made. Carly prob will win but find her voice and persona more suited to the stage. Beatrice has a unique personality which draws you in……that’s what makes a star

  5. disqus_skmFIS6oN8 November 24, 2012 / 5:41 PM

    Cece nneds TO GO…..She can sing but nothing special about her. Plus she sucks 80% of the time. She should of been gone 1st or 2cd. Show. Beatrice has a destinction to her voice. Thats what makes a star. Turning on radio n knowing who it is right away. She had that. Cece DOES NOT…..TIME FOR HER TO GO…..

  6. ofcottawa November 25, 2012 / 10:02 AM

    It’s an absolute joke that Beatrice went home this week and the voters know it. CeCe was pitchy and off-key for the entire performance.. really bad. The hate for CeCe is stronger than ever after she beat Beatrice when the opposite clearly should’ve happened.. she’ll get the lowest amount of votes next week.

Comments are closed.